Evaluating Arguments
Learning Objective
I can determine if an argument is well-supported by examining its reasoning and evidence.
Lesson Flow
Watch Video
Guided Notes
Key concepts students will learn:
- •
When evaluating an argument, it is important to consider whether the evidence presented is both relevant and sufficient to support the conclusion.
- •
Evidence is considered relevant if it is closely related to the claim, and sufficient if there is enough evidence to support the claim.
- •
Even if an argument appears to be strong, it is important to evaluate the evidence to ensure that the conclusions are logical and supported by accurate information.
Practice
9 questions • Multiple choice & Short answer
Exit Ticket
“Read the following argument and evaluate the evidence: 'Cats make great pets. They are soft and furry. My cat likes to eat fish. Cats can be trained to use a litter box.' Is the evidence relevant and sufficient to support the claim that cats make great pets? Explain your answer.”
Teacher Guide
Get the complete package:
- Answer keys for all questions
- Differentiation strategies
- Extension activities
- Printable student handouts
